🔗 Share this article

One of the most iconic photographs of the 20th century portrays an unclothed young girl, her hands outstretched, her expression distorted in terror, her body blistered and raw. She is running in the direction of the camera as fleeing a bombing within the Vietnam War. To her side, youngsters also run from the bombed village in the area, amid a background featuring dark smoke and troops.

This Worldwide Impact of an Powerful Image

Shortly after the publication in the early 1970s, this photograph—originally titled "The Terror of War"—became an analog hit. Viewed and discussed globally, it's generally attributed for energizing worldwide views critical of the US war in Southeast Asia. An influential thinker subsequently observed how the deeply indelible image of nine-year-old the subject suffering likely did more to fuel global outrage toward the conflict than a hundred hours of broadcast barbarities. An esteemed English war photographer who documented the war called it the most powerful photograph from what would later be called “The Television War”. One more veteran war journalist remarked how the picture represents simply put, among the most significant photos ever made, especially of that era.

The Long-Standing Credit Followed by a Modern Allegation

For over five decades, the photo was credited to Nick Út, a young local photojournalist working for the Associated Press at the time. But a controversial latest investigation on a global network claims that the famous photograph—often hailed to be the peak of war journalism—might have been taken by a different man present that day during the attack.

As claimed by the investigation, "Napalm Girl" was in fact taken by a freelancer, who sold his photos to the news agency. The allegation, and its following investigation, originates with a man named an ex-staffer, who states how a powerful bureau head ordered the staff to alter the image’s credit from the freelancer to Nick Út, the only agency photographer on site during the incident.

This Search for the Truth

Robinson, currently elderly, contacted an investigator recently, seeking support in finding the unknown stringer. He expressed that, if he was still living, he wished to extend an acknowledgment. The investigator considered the unsupported stringers he worked with—comparing them to modern freelancers, just as local photographers in that era, are often overlooked. Their contributions is frequently challenged, and they work amid more challenging situations. They have no safety net, no retirement plans, minimal assistance, they frequently lack proper gear, and they are highly exposed when documenting within their homeland.

The investigator wondered: “What must it feel like for the person who took this iconic picture, should it be true that he was not the author?” As a photographer, he thought, it must be profoundly difficult. As an observer of photojournalism, specifically the celebrated documentation of Vietnam, it could prove groundbreaking, perhaps reputation-threatening. The respected legacy of "Napalm Girl" in the community meant that the creator who had family emigrated during the war was reluctant to engage with the film. He said, I was unwilling to unsettle the accepted account attributed to Nick the image. I also feared to disturb the current understanding within a population that consistently respected this achievement.”

The Search Progresses

But both the filmmaker and his collaborator felt: it was important asking the question. “If journalists are going to hold everybody else in the world,” said one, it is essential that we are willing to ask difficult questions of ourselves.”

The investigation tracks the team in their pursuit of their research, from discussions with witnesses, to requests in modern the city, to examining footage from additional films recorded at the time. Their efforts eventually yield an identity: a freelancer, a driver for NBC that day who sometimes worked as a stringer to foreign agencies on a freelance basis. In the film, an emotional Nghệ, like others in his 80s and living in the US, attests that he handed over the photograph to the AP for a small fee and a print, only to be haunted without recognition for decades.

The Backlash and Further Scrutiny

Nghệ appears in the film, thoughtful and reflective, but his story proved controversial in the community of photojournalism. {Days before|Shortly prior to